Software and Firmware for Embedded Systems

It is common for the majority to get confused with the terms “Embedded firmware” and “Embedded software”. In this article, we will discuss differences and similarities between embedded software and firmware and offer examples to help the reader differentiate between those two.

We will kick things off by getting to know what an embedded system is and exploring its core components. From there, we’ll dive into the challenges that developers encounter, from the intricate world of clocking mechanisms to navigating the nuances of firmware and managing power efficiently.

What is an Embedded System?

An embedded system is a computer system with a specific function, composed of a microprocessor, memory, and various input/output peripherals. These systems are often found within larger mechanical or electronic assemblies, hence the term “embedded”.

Embedded systems come in various forms, with some being standalone devices, while others function as integral parts of a larger system.

These systems have a presence in a wide range of applications, including industrial machines, consumer electronics, agricultural and processing equipment, automobiles, medical devices, cameras, digital watches, household appliances, airplanes, vending machines, toys, and even modern mobile devices.

Embedded systems consist of hardware and software components. The hardware includes microprocessor or microcontroller, memory, input/output interfaces, timers, and a power supply. These components require software and firmware to bring them to life and function as a system.

Challenges in Embedded Systems

Embedded product developers grapple with a multitude of challenges as they strive to design and develop efficient and reliable embedded systems. Here, we’ll explore some of the key challenges:

Clocking Challenges

• Synchronization: Achieving precise clock synchronization across different components within an embedded system is crucial for seamless operation. Variations in clock timing can lead to synchronization issues and data errors.
• Low Power Clocking: Balancing the need for high-performance clock speeds with power efficiency is a constant challenge, especially in battery-operated devices.
• Clock Domain Crossing: Managing different clock domains within a single system can be complex and requires careful attention to avoid synchronization problems.

Power Management Challenges

• Energy Efficiency: Balancing performance and power consumption is critical, especially in battery-powered devices. Achieving optimal energy efficiency while maintaining functionality is a constant struggle.
• Dynamic Power Management: Efficiently managing power in dynamic workloads, where system components operate at varying levels of activity, is a complex task.
• Thermal Management: Preventing overheating and thermal issues in embedded systems, which can affect performance and longevity, is another challenge.

Firmware Challenges

• Complexity: Developing firmware that is robust, efficient, and adaptable can be a significant challenge. Firmware must handle various tasks, from hardware control to communication protocols.
• Security: Ensuring the security of embedded systems is paramount. Firmware vulnerabilities can expose systems to cyber threats, making robust security measures essential.
• Compatibility: Firmware must often interact with diverse hardware components, requiring compatibility testing and updates as hardware evolves.

GUI and Dashboards in Embedded Systems

Graphical User Interfaces (GUIs) and dashboards play a crucial role in embedded systems, as they provide an interactive and user-friendly way to control and monitor devices and systems with limited computing resources.

What is Embedded Software?

Embedded software is designed to operate in SWaP optimized non-PC devices. This software is designed for the specific hardware it runs on and often faces some problems due to limited processing power and memory capacity of the device.

A simple example of embedded software can be a controlling of household lighting using an 8-bit microcontroller with minimal memory. It can also be as complex as the software powering modern smart cars. These complex systems manage various electronic components, such as climate control, adaptive cruise control, collision detection, and navigation.

Embedded software and application software differ primarily in their scope and functionality. Embedded software is often serving as the device’s operating system itself. It operates under strict limitations imposed by the device’s functionality, which tightly controls the updates and additions to ensure compatibility.

On the other hand, application software provides specific functionality within a general-purpose computer and operates on a complete OS. This separation means that application software has more flexibility and fewer restrictions when it comes to utilizing system resources.

What is Embedded Firmware?

Firmware serves as a link between the hardware and other software applications that power the system. It is a special type of embedded software that was historically written in read-only memory (ROM) or electrically erasable programmable read-only memory (EEPROM). These earlier forms of firmware were notably unchangeable after initial programming. That is why it is called “firm”.

However, technology has evolved and moved toward storing firmware in Flash memory devices. This advancement offers notable advantages, including easier reprogramming and upgrade capabilities as well as significantly increased storage capacity when compared to its ROM and EEPROM predecessors.

Summing up, the primary role of firmware is to initiate device’s startup process and provide the essential orchestration to support the operation among various hardware components.

Hardware developers use embedded firmware for controlling hardware devices and their functionality similar to the way OS controls the function of software applications. Embedded firmware exists in everything from simple appliances that have computer control, like toasters, to complex tracking systems in missiles. The toaster would likely never need updating but the tracking system sometimes does.

The key difference between Embedded Software vs Firmware

Firmware is just a specific subset of embedded software. Without the operating system and middleware parts, firmware acts as a directional translator only and cannot work without other software layers working on top of it. It is just one layer, whereas a full embedded layer stack is required for a device to function.

Unlike the application software which is updated often, firmware is typically not updated after it is released and  working properly.

If we use a traffic light system analog here is how the embedded system components fit – Hardware (red) is the most difficult to update on a working product, firmware (orange) is not impossible but comes with challenges, and software (green) is easy to update and something that is being updated frequently.

Interested to know more? Get in touch with us for details.